Speak Truth To Power and Fear No Evil
Nov. 13th, 2009 04:29 pm“We are most true to ourselves when we are inconsistent" ~Oscar Wilde
Shockingly, enough people are weird. And more than that they are human, fallible, and fragile, I just think the world ought to know that. Or know that I know that.
I am mediating by nature. I really hate to see people upset with each other, especially when it is clearly a misunderstanding. I have been striking friendly peace-treaties between friends since about third grade. Apparently, I also listen well. It's weird, and I don't know where it comes from, but there it is. As a result, I've been put in the middle of what would be, were it not for my knowledge of the statement I opened my post with, incredibly awkward. But they weren't and it made me realize things about human nature that I feel are worth writing about (also, did I mention that I haven't posted since august? I don't know how it got to be November, really).
I have a very interesting relationship with Christianity; think theology is very interesting so I have been attending a discussion group one of my friends runs called "Christian Faith and Doubt." More often the Token-Catholic (who is the co-leader of the group) and I (The Funky-Protestant-Turned Jew-Turned Quaker-Turned who really knows anymore) are diversity among six or seven main-line Protestant, Youth Group raised, but also very perceptive, very intelligent girls. This week's topic was about what it means to be a Christian.
Let's just say this is a divisive topic, way more than I expected. I came to the discussion hoping for answers, rather than with something to contribute. I am revisiting Christianity (it went out the window with my childhood church and my belief in a simple theology in about sixth grade) more than I ever expected, and I am trying to figure out if Christian is something I want to call myself or can reasonably call myself.
(I am in the awkward position of really liking a lot about liberal Christianity, except that divinity of Christ part, which is a whole other post. In some ways I am a messianic Jew in reverse: they want Christ without the Christianity, and I want Christianity without Christ. This is a problem. I can't ask the Christians that I have been hanging out with (and by hanging out with I mean going to Taize services with) to be anything less than they are, which is fully Christian. But I also can't ask myself to be any more than I am which is not Christian.)
So the discussion moved towards the difference between someone who IS Christian and someone who IS NOT Christian, and there was, as could be expected differences about what is the tipping point between what is and what is not: The Trinity? So much for the Mormons, Rest on Sundays: So much for the Seventh-Day Adventists, The Golden Rule: Well, that's pretty universal. The particulars of the discussion are unimportant, but things were said and they heard as exclusionary, even if they weren't meant that way.
So at about 8:30 my mediating "C'mon guys this isn't worth killing each other over" instinct sent in and no one really intended to hurt anyone's feelings, so we got through it. But more than anything, the leaders of the group felt like they had behaved badly, and they had put me in a funny place by having to mediate (they don't know much of the theological stuff) and made it clear that they were apologetic.
Maybe the leaders did behave badly, I don't think they did, but maybe they did. And maybe I should have been uncomfortable with the fact that I had to mediate a little, but I wasn't. And I really didn't mind being in the position I was, it was natural and normal and instinctual. The discussion is clearly a fraught one, but I don't think we should shy away from it because of that, or even more so for fear of making people uncomfortable. That's how we learn and grow, by being uncomfortable, by getting upset, by letting each other know that we are upset and dealing with it. By accidentally upsetting people, taking it with good graces, and dealing with that. And by letting ourselves be the fallible, fragile, weird people we are.
I remain,
Georgie